Yup, I'll bet on broke. I have broken my toes so many times and the foot bones too. Treasure and Glow love to tread on me. Drs have all said no cast just rest, elevate, wrap if necessary but otherwise just wait to heal. Hurts don't it? Try liquid childrens motrin a whole dose cup! Great for pain and really fast! wear a heavy wool sock on that foot in the boot, try to walk on your heel more and find some steel toed boots. I did, steel toed sneakers too!