[SIZE=12pt]Both my Mom & I have rope halters for our boys, as well as regular, flat nylon ones. (& synthetic leather ones as well.) They are definently more responsive with the rope halter, & on days when they are feeling real frisky I'll go for the rope halter rather then a flat halter, simply because they have more respect for the rope halter & it leads to a more enjoyable time for both of us.[/SIZE]
I don't think that in responsible, common sense hands a rope halter's abusive, same with a halter with a stud chain. Though the pressure each applies is very different. At times I've used a stud chain in combination with a flat halter, if I think they need a little bit of a reminder of manners. I think the key with both a rope halter & stud chain is quick correction & then reward, don't just keep pressure on. (dulls the effect) Also there shouldn't be consistant fighting with them, give them the benifent of doubt, they might not understand what your asking.
That said, I use my rope halter for most everything (when i do use it) except tying unsupervised (i will tie with it if i'm not leaving for any amount of time.), & I never leave it (or any other halter) on while loose. I love to lunge with mine as well, but with another rope tied on, no snap on the lead rope(heavy) so the level of communication is light & sensitive.
In response to Andrea's post, I don't think you
need a rope halter on most miniatures, but I have to say there is a very light sensitive 'dialogue' going on when you use a rope halter.(Similar to Driving/riding with a reins & a bit.) I've achieved
almost as much sensitivity with a regular halter as well. I've noticed that using the rope halter it also fine tuned communication with a regular halter as well. My horse says rope halter, properly fitted are just as comfortable as flat halters.
I'm not die-hard 'rope halter' but I do think properly used, it is a great thing. & it obviously works for some & not all.