I've bought several horse toys with limited luck, mostly they like to play with the feed dishes, but... I bought a jolly ball for my dog, she's passed, so it went back to the horses; they weren't thrilled with it, but its in my stallion's run and he sometimes plays with it. Then, I bought a Jolly Apple, they are hard plastic and meant to be hung up; first horse never touched it, when the next one moved into that run, I took it down and threw it on the ground, he loves it; pushes and it kicks it all over his run (the hard plastic makes a distinct noise when he's playing with it). I had to buy a new one this winter, not because the first was wrecked, but its lost in a snowbank, and I'm not shovelling that much snow (the jolly ball is in there too). Come spring he'll have two, and I can put one away for next winter's bury.