I have fed Nature's Variety: Prairie brand (a high quality food) for almost 5 years now. I love my dogs on it....but now I can't get the Beef variety up here any more, which is what I usually feed with the odd bag of Venison variety (which are the only 2 'flavours' my dogs like and do well on-one gets hot spots from Chicken, one won't eat the Lamb, and none of them seem to like the Salmon all that well). I have started to switch over to Orijen...since I can't get NV Beef, I end up primarily feeding the Venison, and well, the Orijen is cheaper than the Venison....and the Orijen is also a better quality feed. My dogs seem to be doing really well on Orijen.
While they were on Prairie, I never added ANY supplements, and I had many, MANY compliments on their coats! The Orijen doesn't seem to have taken away from that...but I've only been feeding it for a few weeks so far.
I have one dog on a completely raw diet.....since it was having some skin problems, a breeder suggested I switch over to raw. He has been on raw for 3 months now, and once the skin problems are 'fixed' (it's almost better now), I will be switching him to a kibble. I have had a heck of a time getting weight on him (which I heard this past week can be a problem with some dogs on raw), his coat is worse than the ones on kibble (and yes, I realize that the skin problems are mostly to blame for that, but everyone keeps telling me, the raw will fix that....it hasn't), his poops were waaaayyyyy bigger than they were on kibble......and well, I just don't think the raw is agreeing with him that well...kinda like people, some can eat some things with out a problem, the next it just doesn't work.
I had to put him on probiotics and digestive enzymes, which I did about 3 weeks ago. Since doing that, his poops have decreased in size, and he has finally started putting some weight on....but I am feeding him THREE TIMES what I should be.....and it is costing me a fortune! He is also on 'marine oil' (Omega 3-6-9) supplement.
I am totally for raw food, but for some reason it just doesn't seem to be giving my guy the 'extra benefits'....don't know what I'm doing wrong....
~kathryn