I agree with Jen as far as the trophies go. I am all for useful stuff. Queensboro shirt company offers REALLY good deals on shirts, fleece jackets, etc and they'll do the embroidery for free and there is no set up fee either. The more you order, the cheaper it is. Letting people choose what they want is also a good idea. TSC is pretty close to me and I'd be more then happy with a gift certificate, but for someone else, it may not be so close and they'll never use it. Having a list of items you can choose from would make sure everyone got something they'll love and that would give people the option on a trophy as well if they'd rather have that. I love getting stuff I can use- coolers, buckets, sheets, shirts/jackets to wear, etc. Starfish Tack does leather halters that fit Mini's(I think it's a full sized horse halter in suckling size that she has) and you can get a brass plate put on with something like 2007 MMHC Champion or something.
~Jen~