She is gorgeous! The color is very similar, unfortunately, smoky black or buckskin was my first guess, and he is negative for cream. I'm not too familiar with nd1, could it cause all the black to fade off bays? I should have done the full color panel instead of testing one by one, I may have to do that. He doesn't have the lighter colored inner ears. A liver chestnut is a possibility, but according to the color calculator chestnut was only like 3% possible.