It is funny that this subject came up today as a good mini friend and I were talking about the exact same question last night as we prepare to do an auction next month. Most of you know we have been in the midst of a herd reduction here at Cherrville Farms so it has been somewhat interesting to take a look at what we decided to keep and what we decided to turn loose of when coming from a high of 167 horses down to the 40 - 50 we want the herd at.
Basically we have broken it down to a few things.
First those horses that have heart strings tied to them for Cindy/I and will die here. Thankfully those turned out to be some of the best producers also so that helped a bunch.
But then the culling had to start, we go thru a culling every year and that makes it difficult to say the least on the brood mares and stallions. Most have produced world or national champions for us or they would not still be here. And then there were those in the yearling and two year old pastures that we wanted to let mature a little more before we let them go and still deserve a chance to grab the golden ring.LOL
Those horses in the yearling and two year old pastures comprised about 40 of the herd and we let them start leaving to folks that were interested in showing them or wanted particular bloodlines for their herds. Additionally folks that had expressed interest in the past about particular mares or babies we contacted and reduced pricing in order to make them affordable for those folks on some previously not for sale horses.
Now we are down to the final 65 - 70 horses and it has started to get tough to say the least. Our decisions are now made on the following prerequisites: (not in any order of preference)
1. Past production of quality babies. This is made somewhat easier by over 25 years of results to look at.
2. Bloodlines we want in the herd that have proven compatible with the stallions we will be keeping.
3. Current trends in the industry as far as what is winning in the show ring and how we feel the future production of these horses will match up.
4. Soundness of conformation and ability to produce horses that can and will have movement and/or halter ability.
5. The visual comparison of the horse in question to what we like to look at in a mini and consider to be a great horse.
6. What we personally enjoy from a size, color and type in a mini. This is where Cindy and I have some pretty heated discussions as she likes little and I like big as a general rule just as an example. LOL
The bottom line is, that this is the part of the industry we like the best, Long Term breeding! Making plans, culling each year, trying different combinations to see what works and attempting to produce the perfect mini in mind, spirit and body that we possibly can. We will see if we made the right choices in the years to come. And how many of the horses we let go end up turning out to be better in the show ring and breeding pens for others.
Great topic by the way and I am enjoying the input form all the other posters. Thanks for starting it JNK!!!