georgiegirl said:
I would appreciate it if there could be some input on the pros and cons of kicking straps.
Pros: They help teach the horse that bucking and kicking are not acceptable (or possible) in the cart. They act as insurance- hopefully the horse will never need it, but if he starts wildly kicking the strap can save both of you from serious injury by keeping the horse's legs down below the shafts. The strap is easy to use and quick to put on. Properly adjusted, it does not interfer with the horse's movement or comfort in any way unlike a tight check, which some people will tell you is an anti-bucking device.
Cons: It's one more thing to buckle every time you put-to. It
is one more piece of leather on the horse and can make the picture pretty crowded if it isn't placed properly. Some ADS judges still feel a kicking strap is a sign you aren't confident of your horse or isn't proper turnout and may mark you down, just as they did for helmets when people first started wearing those. Kicking straps cannot be used for multiple hitches as they depend on having two shafts so the horse must lift the weight of the cart with his body if he tries to buck. That means they don't help for pulling sleds, working in pairs, for a tandem leader, etc.
Personally, I just take the kicking strap off right before our class at the horse's first couple of shows and later take it off any time we switch to our fancy show harness. The horse only wears it for routine workouts and trail drives where looks do not matter but safety most certainly does. (As you'll see on that safety thread, I had cause to regret leaving the strap at home "just one time" when I took a green horse out at the Kentucky Horse Park.)
georgiegirl said:
Do they really do the job?
Yes. Using one broke my chronic high-spirits bucker of the habit and successfully prevented him from being able to kick out each time he tried in a variety of carts. He was forced to redirect his behavior into moving forward and learned to respect my requests to quit and drive on. Now he will stop when I ask whether or not the strap is on.
georgiegirl said:
What about the straps that connect to the crupper. Do they make the tail area sore if they are properly installed?
I don't personally like the crupper models. My Iowa Valley kicking strap fits over the rump on most of my harnesses and works fine there but when I tried to apply it to my Camptown harness it didn't fit over the backstrap and I had to put it in front of the crupper. It bent the winter hairs in the area, got caught in the buckles, irritated my horse and did not work as well. When he tried to buck in irritation at the way it was pulling on his tail it didn't hold him down, it just made him tuck his butt and go into a crowhopping temper tantrum instead of kicking up and out like he wanted to. Maybe a model designed to work in that area would function better but I still prefer the models that go over the top of the hip. The ones Camptown sells are meant to work with their harnesses and fit fine over the backstrap.
georgiegirl said:
I notice that very few of drivers use them. I dont feel the need for one right now, but I am getting some other feedback that indicates that they are not a bad idea.
Very few mini drivers use them, mostly because none of us were taught about them!
They've been common in training big horses for many years and I wish I'd known about them when I started my gelding. Bucking would never have become a habit for him if I had.
Farina said:
At first I think that a properly trained driving hrse shouldn't need kicking straps.
A definitive pro for kicking straps is, that you can adjust them in different positions so you can give your horse a more balanced look. There is only one position for breeching, and sometimes horses look very long in their back with breeching. I would never use breeching and kicking strap, that loooks like too many leather with too few horse.
Okay, I'm open to the idea that this is a cultural difference but in my opinion the kicking strap is absolutely the one piece of harness where looks aren't a consideration.
It is a piece of SAFETY equipment, and if it's on there it's on to do its job, not make the horse's back look shorter. It goes where-ever it needs to in order to prevent bucking. Breeching actually is adjustable and both can and should be moved to sit at the most correct and visually pleasing spot on the horse's back. If it is too far back, yes, it can make the back look long.
I consider a kicking strap to be part of the proper training process. I will put one on my green horses for them to wear even (in fact especially if) they haven't offered to buck as I want them to hit that strap at least once and realize that bucking in the cart is not acceptable. The colt I will be starting next year is going to be wearing one full-time for awhile because just like Andrea's colt, he's more than a bit of a lightfoot behind! His first reaction to anything is to kick out or at least hump his butt and bounce. Should he do that in the cart and hit the basket he could panic himself and cause a terrible accident. I'm going to be desensitizing him very strongly in the next year and working to redirect his behavior into freezing in place or at least turning to face what scares him instead of turning his butt to it and he'll get trained in an open bridle at first so he knows there's something behind him and isn't startled when his foot hits something. I think between those precautions and the kicking strap he'll be an awesome driving horse in a year or two and pretty trustworthy. He does not kick aggressively, only in defensiveness, so if I can keep him from feeling threatened as he learns his job we should be fine.
I can post some pictures of the strap I use when I get home from work.
Leia