I haven't read all of this thread -- when I have a free week, I may
OH!
First, as a horse owner, I am aware that EVERY horse in ANY breed or breeding program can (& probably does) have a conformation flaw. Also, it is quite obvious and proven than minis did not evolve from the gods, but from crosses of various pony breeds.....in some proportion of their background. Plus I am aware that some of the "older" farms had dwarves in breeding -- both as the result and as the parent.
When I began with minis my goal was strictly "28 & under". That is what I wanted to breed and to this day they are still my hearts favorite and I freely admit that they are not
as a whole the most fluid in motion or conformation. The challenge is huge to downsize and maintain tremendous proportion.
I have never had a dwarf to date. I carefully looked at backgrounds and attempted to not include any who may have shown parentage that was what I felt was dwarf. I have accepted that some animals had poorer conformation in their lineage but, having looked at the offspring as best I could, felt it was conformational and not "dwarf". PLUS, I gotta tell you that not every lineage on those papers is TRUE!! OK, I also was very, very, very much for, and promoted, DNA -- STILL want PQ to be required!!! -- and I had my entire herd DNA'd to be able to help with the purification of lineage truth. Some farms were more inclined to have the dwarf genetics and it was obvious, not just one conformation issue, but many. A farm that has long been defunct...Hobby Horse....here in VA, had an entire field of very obvious dwarfs and he wanted big bucks for these tiny animals. Some of other sections of his farm had beautiful animals. I thanked him and left.
There is a mare in my field whom I have owned since 93 and I have never, ever bred her -- although she has produced some nice offspring for others. She had too many not desireable conformation issues which I did not want to consider producing......not dwarf, just not desireable. She is 20 or 21 now and a wonderful baby sitter. Doesn't eat much, healthy, lovely personality
She was purchased unseen, from a well known farm and I retired her when she arrived! I have a Little Husseler dtr who is a tiny spitfire, 24 now, and she has given me some of THE best foals ever -- big action, great conformation. So, there you go.
Some of my carefully selected Komoko mares have been my best producers.
Personally, I agree with those who can just say --
1)do not breed those who are in left field conformationally
2) there really are those who are not dwarfs and have flaws, love them & don't breed them
3)dwarfs happen
4)improve as much as you can.....know there will always be pet quality & non registered stock
5) not every breeder produces themselves. Some produce better, some worse. Use the better one.
For all the new people, just know that these issues exist. Hopefully we will be able to test DNA in the future and determine some of these issues medically. Wouldn't that be great?? Ya know what, we will never be able to test for the "poor conformation" -- only your eye can do that. Love them anyway.